[ Carl has looked into his eye when he uncovered it. It was disgusting, unnatural. There's a hole in his face, there should have been clear-blue eye there. But it's just gone. Destroyed. But the rest of his face was not. But he still carries that hole, like he carries the holes within his own memory. He doesn't remember the crash - just noises of it. So maybe they are telling the truth of that, perhaps? ]

And you don't remember anything of it? I don't remember the car crash that took my eye, but I do remember hearing some sudden crashing noise. I think they are telling the truth I lost my eye with the crash.